PhD Thesis on Social Presence, Chapter 4: Negotiation of Meaning

PhD Thesis on Social Presence, Chapter 4: Negotiation of Meaning

This post presents one section of Chapter 4 of my PhD thesis on social presence in online language learning, examining how negotiation of meaning influences learners’ social presence and interactivity. It explores the effectiveness of synchronous activities, including round tables and argue for/against debates, alongside asynchronous collaborative writing and discussion forums. The findings highlight the importance of cross-cultural interaction, learner autonomy, and effective teacher facilitation in fostering meaningful communication, balanced participation, and collaborative learning.

Results of Q6: The Influence of Negotiation of Meaning on Social Presence

Throughout the study, it was observed that whenever our round tables became markedly cross-cultural, our experience in our negotiation of meaning would respectively become more intense and heated. To exemplify this point, in our open-ended questionnaire, Amir, L. Soleimani and Nafiseh announced that whenever N. Iman from Pakistan, N. Jahan from Bangladesh, J. Shaikh from India or Zhanara from Kazakhstan were present in our negotiations, they and the other Iranian participants as the negotiators would become more enthusiastic and involved.

Our cross-cultural negotiations had a major problem. According to S. Nasiri’s completed questionnaire, due to an arbitrary and unsystematic approach to determining the proficiency level of the participants, a mixture of learners with various proficiency levels in English caused the more proficient ones to monopolize our negotiations by assuming more active roles in our synchronous voice-based classes, thus frustrating the less proficient learners. According to Hiltz and Wellman (1997), if online teachers’ managerial techniques do not suffice, more proficient and enthusiastic students might tend to “overload others by writing voluminous and numerous messages” (Hiltz & Wellman, 1997, p. 48), a phenomenon which is referred to as information overload (Hiltz & Wellman, 1997).

In our semi-structured interviews, Niaz expressed her appreciation to the researcher/teacher for not stopping her and the other participants in negotiations again and again like the majority of teachers – as she claimed it – because students who are interrupted by the teacher repeatedly tend to lose their confidence and become rather shy. With regard to the role of the teacher in guiding negotiations, S. Ghomi, in his open-ended questionnaire, confirmed that the researcher was successful in “motivating the students to use all of their abilities and potential to develop necessary language skills for the negotiations”.

In one call for feedback section, S. Daliri, S. Ghomi and T. Ghanooni largely concurred with this view that the researcher, unlike in other activities, should not intervene in the natural flow of conversation among the students. According to S. Daliri, the teacher’s intervention in our argue for/against activity could thwart the students from experiencing a heated argument or negotiation of meaning. He also added that we should spend more time on this “great activity”. S. Ghomi stated that, especially in our negotiations, the teacher should be completely neutral so that the students could express their ideas freely. Conversely, Z. Rousta, in the same interview, asserted, “the teacher is a human, so he/she should be free to express their ideas, too”. Shortly afterward, she explained that she had found it “useful and helpful” when the teacher clearly expressed his own ideas in our negotiations.

Openly advocating the expression of ideas on the part of the teacher, F. Rezanejad explained in her questionnaire that the teacher ought not to impose his/her opinions upon the students. On the contrary, the teacher should be “respectful” of the students’ points of view. In our group interviews, F. Rezanejad continued that she did not approve of a neutral teacher in the negotiations because it was interesting for her and the other students to know about the teacher’s viewpoints in our discussions. Later on, she further insisted that if the students clash with each other over heated debates, “the teacher should guide the students” and control frenzied and bitter disputes by, for example, providing plausible and convincing reasons.

F. Rezanejad expressed her gratefulness to the teacher/researcher for being completely unbiased and impartial, particularly from the commencement of our negotiations. According to F. Rezanejad, the teacher’s intentional initial impartiality in our arguments was so effective in leading fair arguments. Later on, at the end of the arguments when we were supposed to arrive at an informed conclusion, as F. Rezanejad stated, the teacher clarified his points of view because the students wanted to listen to his opinions, as well.

The teacher’s particular role that the majority of the participants accentuated was facilitation of learning, an almost technical term that, to the researcher’s own astonishment, all of the fixed participants, including H. Zanjani, S. Daliri, S. Nasiri and T. Ghanooni, were familiar with. To be more specific, while focusing on rather difficult topics, such as placebo effect, the participants appreciated the researcher’s endeavor to activate their past experience and background information to initiate the discourse.

On many occasions, the participants as negotiators showed a great tendency to digress from the main point for a variety of reasons, including lacking sufficient information as a result of no preparation, a paucity of interest in the topics, etc. This was one of the rare instances that the researcher would intentionally mediate the distorted course of conversations, which was not favored by some students who had a thirst for chaos. However, some negotiators like H. Hosseini favored our “thoroughly concentrated and organized negotiations” (as he labeled them in a group interview) by virtue of applying our class regulations, according to which the other students and the teacher could veto any comment or question in case of being irrelevant (respectively peer-assessment and teacher-assessment).

T. Ghanooni, in an individual interview with the researcher, reprimanded him for speaking too much in our negotiations. She suggested that the teacher divide the students into small groups so that the students could talk to each other more interactively at least for a while without the teacher’s domineering presence. Meanwhile, the teacher could listen to and monitor the students’ interaction closely and inform the learners of the errors and mistakes that they make in using the language, a criticism which was openly accepted and implemented in the second phase of the procedure, particularly in our argue for/against activity, which was thoroughly explained in Chapter 3.

Asynchronous negotiation of meaning both in our comment forms and on discussion forums appeared to be a reasonably appropriate method for practicing reflectivity among the participants because, according to Chapelle and Jamieson (2008), written conversations can provide practical opportunities for learners to slow down the conversation in order to monitor and reflect upon what they are trying to communicate. Furthermore, written negotiation of meaning on our challenging topics in our English conversation classes furnished the students and the teacher/researcher with a visual record or log of our interactions both linguistically and pragmatically, and particularly linguistically, by giving this chance to the learners to focus on the linguistic details of their own social contributions (comments, replies, questions, etc.) that they might have missed in our synchronous voice-based negotiations.

Discussion of Q6: The Influence of Negotiation of Meaning on Social Presence

Our argue for/against activity to practice negotiation of meaning, which was implemented in the second phase of the study on Discord, raised the level of online communication and interactivity among the learners in a synchronous mode. This group-based problem-solving and brainstorming activity, from the participants’ perspectives reflected in their questionnaires and interviews, was one of the most collaborative educational activities they had ever experienced in the field of language learning. In this activity, the teacher’s presence was basically and consciously restricted to a fair observer unless he was invited to play a part in the discussion and express his viewpoints.

Consequently, the learners were mindfully educated to become independent of the teacher in reflecting upon the thought-provoking stimulus, revealing their orientations toward it by entering the corresponding voice channels, finding evidence to argue for/against the stimulus through collaborative brainstorming while taking notes in approximately two minutes, and ultimately striving to convince their opponents that they were right in the argument with reference to their evidence.

Through asynchronous interactive writing tasks (e.g., our collaborative writing activity), the L2 learners are motivated to exercise optimum negotiation of meaning for the sake of clarification in a low-anxiety environment because, first of all, their task is collectively (not individually) assessed, and second of all, they have plenty of time to examine the preceding writing tasks written by their classmates, assess them, and finally make their own contribution. The fulfilment of negotiation of meaning in a low-anxiety atmosphere in collaborative writing activities, which was investigated in this study, has also been studied and vindicated by Abrams (2001).

Our negotiation-raising activities, namely round table and argue for/against, proved to be effective in augmenting the level of interactivity and social presence among the participants in spite of the fact that the students could not see each other and use nonverbal communication. If negotiations reflect sufficient intensity grounded on challenging, exciting, informative and useful topics, then the L2 learners do not need to be visually stimulated to actively and responsively participate in negotiation of meaning.

Applying negotiation of meaning in CALL programs to account for communicative language teaching (CLT) encourages the students to utilize technology as a vehicle for practicing and learning English through natural and meaningful discourse (Chapelle & Jamieson, 2008). The findings of this study corroborate the results of Towndrow’s (2004) research about the efficacy of problem-solving activities and scaffolding in online L2 courses to encourage the students to interact with each other with the purpose of asking for clarification and providing feedback on challenging subjects for discussion.

Inviting the participants, especially with various cultural backgrounds, to take part in our intensely challenging negotiations was subject to some criticism. Consistent with Botha’s (1982) findings on the significance of cultural differences in L2 verbal communication, which might lead to a breakdown in communication, irrespective of acknowledging myriads of advantages derived from cross-cultural academic settings in our global village, this study is also indicative of some rare but acrimonious quarrels that occasionally arise and are deeply rooted in the clash of ideologies and cultural differences among the participants that are interacting with each other from distant parts of the world.

With regard to the teacher’s presence and role in holding virtual negotiation of meaning, it is noteworthy to mention again that the two distinguished features of our virtual classes, i.e. content development on the part of the students and the meticulous selection of topics in terms of being informative, challenging, multifaceted and exciting were of great assistance to bring about more intense negotiation of meaning because of the fact that the negotiators were more acquainted with the details of the assigned topics, which were enticing and thrilling to them.

The asynchronous activities occurring before our oral negotiations and in preparation for them in our comment forms, discussion boards, and public chat rooms with the log of previous events alongside content creation on the part of the students generally led to the collection and digestion of so much relevant information in conjunction with our selected topics. Accordingly, in almost all of our conversation classes, the negotiators were so well-prepared for an informed participation that the researcher himself was excited to learn many things from the them without feeling the necessity of establishing his general dominance in the negotiations.

The students’ asynchronous interactive activities in our comment forms and discussion boards appeared to be helpful and advantageous to practice negotiation of form, which was of minor importance in this study. The learners’ social contributions in preparation for our round table and, specifically, collaborative writing activities were of practical value to our participants and the entire community because the students could perform asynchronous peer-assessment to promote more attention, autonomy and interactivity. For instance, with regard to our collaborative writing activity, since negotiation of form had to occur prior to negotiation of meaning (i.e., cohesion prior to coherence) so that the essayists could compose a cohesive, coherent, and unified essay, the learners’ collaborative activities were so elaborate and self-sufficient that, most of the time, we did not spend any time on this activity (i.e., collaborative writing) in our synchronous classes.

The analysis of the transcribed semi-structured interviews surprisingly indicated that even our most teacher-dependent participants preferred that the teacher be unbiased, impartial and nonjudgmental, particularly in our oral synchronous negotiations taking place in our lecture delivery, argue for/against and round table activities. To be more precise, in our call for feedback sessions, the participants suggested that the teacher should not interject the negotiators or try to intervene in the natural flow of synchronous conversations whose main partakers are the language learners. On the other hand, as one independent negotiator, the teacher was occasionally invited by the curious participants to articulate his ideas, especially in our round tables, which was completely natural. In this case, the researcher mindfully expressed his opinions in the last part of our round tables, i.e. reaching for a conclusion, lest he and his perspectives should monopolize the conversations.

As implied in the previous paragraph, the teacher’s interjection or intervention in negotiation of meaning could have more deleterious effects if carried out at the outset of oral negotiations in conversation classes because, in so doing, the teacher would voluntarily or involuntarily exert considerable influence over the general orientation of the conversations. The online English teachers, particularly those teaching conversation classes, ought to note that their classes are primarily language classes and secondarily opportunities for exchanging ideas and information vis-à-vis various subject matter. As a consequence, the teacher should not obstinately endeavor to vindicate that he/she is right in the arguments. Instead, it must be attempted to show a neutral position to the topics.

Our participants had not taken standard evaluation tests – except individual interviews with the researcher before following our courses – to specify their proficiency in English. As a consequence, it was noticed that, sporadically, more proficient learners would wield influence over our oral negotiations, although they sometimes had even less technical information about the topics being discussed. This could be disparaging and frustrating in the eyes of the less proficient students. This situation would make the teacher’s presence and role as a fair coordinator more critical.

With regard to S. Nasiri’s criticism about the various proficiency levels of the participants, which was stated in the Results section vis-à-vis effective negotiations, it should be pointed out that the researcher had already thought through this problem and come up with the following solutions. First of all, the participants, especially the less proficient ones, had plenty of time – approximately five days, from Friday to Wednesday – to prepare themselves for forthcoming classes. Moreover, the participants were supposed to take equal turns in our oral discussions (approximately 60 second at a time), which proved to be an appropriate method to thwart the more proficient students from any planned or unplanned monopoly in class activities because, as a general rule, more proficient learners might become overactive in synchronous negotiations in virtual classes.

Leave a Comment