Table of Contents
This section of Chapter 4 of the PhD thesis explores the influence of Content-Based Instruction (CBI) on student interactivity in online English language learning. It examines how thought-provoking topics, student-driven content development, collaborative activities, and inquiry-based learning can enhance learner engagement, autonomy, critical thinking, vocabulary acquisition, and social presence. Drawing on participants’ feedback and research findings, it also discusses the challenges of demanding academic activities, learner motivation, and the transition from traditional teacher-centered instruction to interactive, collaborative, and autonomous learning environments.
Results of Q5: The Influence of CBI on Interactivity
In the light of the observations, it became clear that aside from academic fulfilment and satisfaction on the part of the students, the interest factor was another crucial ingredient of student interactivity and engagement, which was also vividly stated by Azadeh, H. Rezaei, S. Daliri, S. Nasiri and S. Ghomi in their completed questionnaires. That is to say, the L2 learners must develop some interest in online activities, topics and tasks in which they engage in order to augment their interactivity and social presence. In this regard, S. Ghomi, in an individual interview, affirmed that if he were an online English teacher, he would certainly pay special attention to selecting interesting and exciting topics for discussion among his students to catch their attention.
In our round tables based on mainly psychological and academic topics, namely subconscious mind, attraction law, carpe diem, comfort zone, etc., the participants were expected to conduct some research in preparation for our synchronous discussions in our online classes. This inquiry-based approach to uncovering the mysteries of some intricate topics was more noticeably advocated by well-educated participants, for example, F. Rezanejad and M. Gholinezhad who was a senior nurse. On the other hand, through the in-depth analysis of the participants’ feedback in the semi-structured interviews, it was clarified that at the outset of the study, some participants, including H. Hosseini, T. Ghanooni and V. Kalhor, did not literally favor our student-driven CBI approach based on psychological topics, which was the antithesis of the IRF model (Sinclair & Coulthard, 1975, as cited in Waring, 2009) in which the discourse usually commences with the teacher’s stimuli in the form of questions.
In a group interview, T. Ghanooni argued that the IRF model was more preferable because the teacher was more proficient in English. On the other hand, she complained that the course was too demanding because she had to spend a great deal of time interacting with the other students asynchronously to prepare the content of the course in the form of comments, questions, replies, polls, and so forth. She further asserted that although they did not have any final examinations, the students were fully expected to be seriously active even for each individual session. Consequently, in a couple of interviews, she requested that we could take some sessions off intermittently to gain the requisite energy for the course, as she used to do.
S. Ghomi criticized our CBI approach based on abstract and challenging topics for being viable only for students whose level of proficiency is above elementary and pre-intermediate because, according to him, the students need to have some level of computer literacy to be able to conduct some research on the selected topics and prepare themselves for our round tables. This idea was challenged in the same group interview by H. Zanjani in this way that when she started attending our classes (until that time, she had been following our virtual classes for slightly over a year), she was almost an elementary student. However, she had a rapid advancement in her learning.
As implicitly stated in the previous paragraph, the careful selection of our psychological and challenging topics appeared to be an important factor in altering the interaction patterns among the participants. For example, S. Ghomi stated that adequate preparation on the part of the students for the assigned topics was not a high priority for him. Instead, the ambitious participants, including him, attended our virtual course almost exclusively in preparation for international standardized tests, such as TOEFL and IELTS. This criticism leveled at our too challenging and time-consuming topics was also raised by other participants, including S. Nasiri, T. Ghanooni and Z. Rousta, in both their questionnaires and interviews. In an individual interview with S. Nasiri, she said that making the students ponder upon complicated issues and themes had led to seriously narrowing down the range of our participants (i.e., only thoughtful and intellectual ones), which proved to be rather too extreme.
Notwithstanding, the same complaining participants gradually changed their mind about our CBI-based flipped learning approach, particularly in the second phase of the investigation. For instance, in a group interview, V. Kalhor argued that content development on the part of the students was a challenging method through which all of the class activities could be controlled by both the teacher and the students, implying that the students themselves can have some authority to determine the course of activities in the class. F. Rezanejad and H. Zanjani referred to the concept of student authority expressed by V. Kalhor as student autonomy. Our student-driven CBI approach, according to some interviewed participants, e.g. J. Shaikh from India, M. Jalali and M. Yaghubi from Italy, had positive impacts upon the students’ accuracy in English as they were supposed to write relevant questions and reply to their classmates’ questions asynchronously. To be more precise, the very act of having extensive reading on challenging topics to acquire some background information helped the participants to improve their reading skill, especially speed reading, as stated by T. Ghanooni. In addition, Bashir and Mehri, two participants from Denmark, stated that in Denmark, CBI is also practiced. They declared that by means of CBI, they could improve their English proficiency, particularly vocabulary, to be able to understand and decode the message they are exposed to.
In other words, our central focus on psychological and intellectual topics inadvertently caused us to strive to learn many abstract words, phrases, and lexical items to be able to uncover the mysteries of the subject matters, which according to S. Ghomi, was one of the distinct advantages of our theme-based approach. This advantage became even more noticeable when the researcher supplemented each post with a growing collection of over 5500 tags or keywords thematically developed from the participants’ social contributions to the course (i.e., comments, questions, replies, discussion forums, quotations, etc.). Our growing tags, which were located at the bottom of each post, helped the participants to enrich their vocabulary knowledge, especially collocations, because they could search for the tags on other posts in our community to see how they were used in context, something which is technically referred to as concordance.
In her questionnaire, Mehri specified that CBI with a focus on thought-provoking and academic topics together with content development on the part of the students had helped her to reflect profoundly upon important issues in life specifically by assuming more active roles. In his questionnaire, S. Daliri explained that focusing on useful and challenging topics in our round tables had enabled him to distinguish the subtle differences and details between abstract concepts (e.g., comedy vs. satire) with more scrutiny. According to Sam, this ability can alter your perspective in life, thus changing the course of life for the better. In a group interview, F. Rezanejad announced that our classes, especially round tables, had a profound effect on her life and she could learn about various psychologically useful subjects within the framework of English.
In our call for feedback sessions, F. Rezanejad and S. Ghomi disagreed with Fatemeh (a participant who quit our course for our exclusive interest in psychological and intellectual topics) and V. Kalhor, claiming that factual topics do not give them this chance to have heated arguments in the class as they are, most of the time, self-explanatory. In an individual interview with H. Rezaei, he announced that the topics were “deep and challenging” for which the students were supposed to “conduct some research, sit down and think” to be able to make a contribution to the course and prepare themselves for the upcoming discussions. Vis-à-vis the influence of our carefully selected topics, H. Rezaei claimed that our special focus on truly challenging and intellectual topics was, in practice, one of the most distinguishing factors of our online society in comparison to its peers.
Upon contemplating the gist of the preceding paragraph, it will become clear that practicing CBI could be a stepping stone toward skill integration because, according to Brown (2007), CBI practitioners ought to get involved in the four skills of reading, writing, listening and speaking in an integrated fashion to collect necessary information about the subject matter, and then discuss the findings in the class with the other students.
F. Rezanejad compared and contrasted our flipped approach to learning with the one that is dominant at schools and universities in this way that even as an M.A. graduate in Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL), she and her classmates basically used to postpone studying for the courses until the last weeks or days. Nonetheless, in our course, initially, they had to, yet subsequently, they were willingly and autonomously creating the content of their own classes. In his questionnaire, H. Rezaei announced that he had never experienced this method in which the students provided the content of the course in an interactive fashion, which led to the development of a profound understanding of what the students were studying as the content of the course.
The findings of this study are basically in proportion to Waring’s (2009) research on the critical reconsideration of the IRF model, according to which establishing a “renewed participation structure that allows for student-initiated negotiations” is advocated (Waring, 2009, p. 796).
Discussion of Q5: The Influence of CBI on Interactivity
CALL materials can provide a mechanism for implementing theoretically-ideal conditions for second language acquisition and carrying out empirical research to explore the effects of these conditions (Hegelheimer & Chapelle, 2000). In this regard, it must be attempted to develop CALL programs and tasks on the basis of the well-established theories and considerations of second language acquisition. According to Ng and Oliver (1987), “for meaningful computer application in language learning it is vital that CALL materials be designed on a theoretical basis, founded upon an understanding of language and language learning” (p. 13).
Experiencing teaching in both face-to-face and virtual language classes has led to the development of this understanding in the researcher that the learners of the latter group are more inclined to focus on the themes and subjects that are more inspiring, intellectual and challenging. This could be due to the immensity of sources that are easily accessible on the web. In this regard, prioritizing thought-provoking and intriguing topics and materials enhances the level of attention in the L2 learners both synchronously and asynchronously. This point is also manifested in both oral and written communication modes. As Chapelle (2001) has argued, written communication is more likely to provide the learners with ample opportunities to practice consciousness-raising activities compared to spoken language, thanks to the visual saliency of incoming and outgoing messages and the ability to create the log of previous messages.
On the other hand, focusing on abstract and intellectual topics provided this opportunity for the learners to feel the necessity of practicing and learning advanced wide vocabulary in fairly practical ways, including paragraph development in our collaborative writing activity, giving presentations in our lecture delivery activity, asynchronous interactivity on the comment forms and discussion boards in our round table activity where they had plenty of time to use their recently learned vocabulary and critically but amicably assess the diction of their peers.
With regard to the special selection of our topics (principally psychological and intellectual ones), it became clear that some of the participants were not literally enticed into the assigned topics or activities because our abstract topics required the learners to give an abundance of profound thought and consideration to the themes and their interaction with their peers, which was not favored by some students. Instead, they were just preoccupied with preparing themselves for some international standardized tests, namely TOEFL and IELTS, and they would not follow the course after passing the exams. Although we were generally successful in motivating many students to follow our online courses by virtue of interesting, useful and challenging topics that largely fell into the category of psychological and abstract subjects to promote argument among the learners, it would be unfair to conceal that we lost some students merely on account of this exclusive selection of topics.
The analysis of the transcribed interviews together with observations cast light on this point that the phenomenon of interdependency was absolutely crucial for the creation and maintenance of social presence in virtual classes, particularly L2 ones. The L2 learners can optimize their learning when they learn in interaction and partnership with each other and from each other. In other words, their success in learning English as a second/foreign language mainly depends on their interaction with their peers and the teacher and their collaborative contribution to the course to fulfill interactive constructivism in language learning.
In a collaborative learning community, learners are encouraged to “develop an ability to think critically about new media genres when they actually go through the process of producing new media rather than just consuming it” (Warschauer, Grant, Real & Rousseau, 2004, p. 534). As a matter of fact, encouraging the students to assume active roles and major responsibilities (e.g., question development for our round table activity, giving presentations in our lecture delivery activity, composing paragraphs interactivity in our collaborative writing activity, etc.) can expedite and facilitate the establishment of social presence among the learners. Assigning responsibilities to the learners can stimulate them to be thoroughly active and responsive with a sense of adventure even in each single session, which was so thrilling even to the researcher.
In our lecture delivery activity in the second phase of the investigation, in which the participants used to give a presentation on free topics lasting for approximately five minutes and then give an interview to the other participants, the learners were making a great contribution to our learning blog (content development) because the researcher, with the lecturers’ permission, recorded and archived their English presentations together with the three questions that they themselves had developed and left as comments to be posed to their audience (i.e., their peers) after their lectures in the following interviews. The growing archive of our recorded English Lectures with corresponding questions available on the blog (so far, 18 lectures) provided excellent materials for our subsequent conversation and listening courses. Therefore, our lecture delivery activity proved to be another effective collaborative task to account for the creation of a sense of belonging in the autonomous learners in the form of content development for subsequent classes.
In our round tables, the students were supposed to determine the topic for our conversations democratically and collaborative by means of our online voting and polling systems. Afterwards, they used to acquire some information about the specified topics, such as carpe diem, attraction law, intuition, subconscious mind, etc. through reading some online sources, including Wikipedia. Later on, they were expected to challenge each other by posing relevant questions to their peers by leaving comments and replies in an asynchronous and interactive manner. Subsequently in our oral discussions, they used to refer to their own interactive contributions on the blog, trying to exchange their ideas and findings with each other to come to a comprehensive conclusion. Accordingly, this inquiry-based approach to language learning was of practical use to the learners, including the teacher, to practice all the four skills (skill integration).
On the significance of a holistic and integrated approach to teaching second/foreign languages online, Farmer and Gruba (2006) argue:
Language learning, of course, does not consist of discrete static processes, nor can many aspects be fully isolated, treated and satisfactorily understood. Rather, language learning is a dynamic, holistic process that relies upon various levels of independent activities that surround it. Given the diversity of learners, activities and conditions, effective CALL software development frameworks must be flexible enough to respond rapidly to changing contexts and requirements (p. 154).
Content development on the part of the students automatically raised the level of their reflectivity, criticality, awareness and engagement in the process of learning. This sense of awareness that was combined with their collaborative activities on the blog, according to Hauck and Warnecke (2013) and Palloff and Pratt (2005), was conducive to the creation of social presence in our blog, which is a more mature online phenomenon compared to sheer interactivity.
The intentionally engineered confluence of selecting psychologically useful topics and content development on the part of the students turned out to be two clearly distinguished features of our virtual learning blog that have been inexorably reminiscent of the title of our online community. These two features have been greatly appreciated by the active members of our community, for they have happened to be more critical, reflective, and open-minded not only in the realm of education, but also with regard to the ultimate purpose of education, which, according to the researcher, is learning how to make necessary informed changes for a better life. As more elaborately stated in the section of Results and the transcribed interviews in Appendix H, in support of the students’ above-mentioned appreciation, which was unexaggerated, they reasoned that having attended our virtual classes alongside their online activities and responsibilities on the blog, they could notice the subtle distinctions between closely-related phenomena, namely comedy and satire and become more profound thinkers.
The reflected ideas of the participants in our call for feedback sections unveiled this point that our round table activity, in spite of promoting interactive communication, had some weak points that were pointed to by some participants. As mentioned earlier in Chapter 3, in this activity, the participants used to pose their developed questions to their peers, and each question was answered merely by one respondent. This anti-dynamic approach to seeking appropriate answers to the existing questions did not allow for any potentially better response to each question. Another weakness of this activity, or in a more general scope, the entire study, was that, according to the supervisor of the research project, the sheer act of developing, posing, and answering questions does not guarantee the realization of social presence in a language learning blog, which was the phenomenon taking place in the first phase of the current investigation. These two weaknesses were identified and overcome in the second phase of the investigation, especially by devising some other activities, such as argue for/against, collaborative writing, photo scanning, lecture delivery, and also the employment of categorized discussion boards, podcasts, and so forth.
On the other hand, the majority of the participants were not accustomed to this method in comparison to more traditional and teacher-driven approaches, such as IRF. As a consequence, the number of the participants could not exceed 42 in a lengthy period of time over one year. Regarding this issue from a broader perspective, content development on the part of the students as an incontrovertible feature of the curriculum cannot be commercially advisable for language faculties based on e-learning owing to the fact that it does narrow down the number of their students or customers to those who have a thirst for formal education and academic activities. Moreover, although these 42 determined students were following our courses, it was noticed that some of them happened to become less active intermittently over the course of time or even show fractious behaviors in our call for feedback sessions, complaining about heavy responsibilities on their shoulders.



